Monday, April 02, 2012
The privatization of the NHS posted by Richard Seymour
My latest for ABC Australia:The rich want healthcare. Believe them about this. They want hospitals, doctor's practices, insurance, patient care, pharmaceutical provision, all of it.Last year, four out of the 10 most profitable industries in the US were healthcare-related. This was due to the fact that these industries were providing services rather than more tangible products, thus keeping overheads low, and the fact that the services were, in the sickly phrase of Forbes magazine, "need-to-have". That is, compulsory. Need to have, or you'll die.This is why healthcare is such a prized asset for businesses, and why they are desperate to crack open health sectors globally. And it is one reason why the British coalition government is undertaking the most fundamental demolition job on the National Health Service since its foundation in 1948.
Labels: capitalism, health care, neoliberalism, new labour, NHS, privatisation, tories
Tuesday, August 10, 2010
NHS shock doctrine posted by Richard Seymour
The NHS support federation has a statement on, and petition against, the government's NHS white paper. Here's a video that roughly explains what it's all about:Labels: 'free markets', capitalism, health care, neoliberalism, new labour, NHS, socialism, tories
Tuesday, July 13, 2010
Tory shock therapy for the NHS is an attack on democracy posted by Richard Seymour
This is the shock doctrine in action. What with the recession and the barrage of propaganda misdirection, and with relatively little militancy in response to job losses and pay cuts so far, the Tories are hoping that people are too busy worrying about their jobs and houses to notice most of what they're doing - such as the latest example redistribution of wealth from the poor to the rich, and the neoliberal reforms of the NHS, which are tantamount to a massive privatization drive. Last year, when the NHS was under attack by the American right, David Cameron had to defend it. Now, the government is on the attack:Announcing his plans, Tory health secretary Andrew Lansley this week said that he wants 80 percent of the NHS budget to be allocated to businesses run by groups of local GPs.
Local primary care trusts and strategic health authorities, which currently buy services for patients, would be abolished.
“These proposals have nothing at all to do with patient care, and everything to do with the needs of big business,” says Gill George, a health worker and member of the Unite union executive.
Lansley claims that his changes would benefit ordinary people by removing key decisions from “faceless bureaucrats” and decentralise power.
But far from making the NHS more democratic, the Tory plans are a ruse for handing yet more of the health service to private firms.
Indeed. The manner in which the ConDem government is attempting to sell neoliberal measures - which are profoundly anti-democratic in taking more and more of the public sector out of the sphere of democratic accountability - as progressive, empowering and democratising, is one of the most insolent and absurd aspects of modern political communication. Privatization, and the neoliberal praxis in which it is embedded, is an attack on democracy. As I have argued elsewhere, this adaptation of the language of progress for regressive ends has a prehistory in the origins of conservative thought, and particularly in the roots of neoliberal ideology.
In this case, the Tories argue that doctors know better than bureaucrats how to run healthcare, and that they intend to entrust decisions over treatment to healthcare professionals. Leaving aside the fact that it will be private firms rather than GPs that take over the running of health trusts - most doctors aren't actually specialists in procurement and health management - this defer-to-the-experts line is in fact a technocratic, rather than democratic, argument, and it runs counter to what makes the NHS a relatively democratic institution. It is because the National Health Service is one of the great achievements of socialism that it has been one of the more democratic aspects of the British state since its inception. This is because democracy is inherently collectivist and egalitarian. Everyone from whatever background has access to treatment when they need it. Relatively impartial information about medical choices is freely available. There is no bill at the end of treatment that would dissuade anyone from seeking treatment just because they're poor, and the tax system that pays for it is modestly progressive. And the NHS is a public good subject to the oversight of elected officials - that's democracy, and it means that 'bureaucratic' oversight is a good thing. In all, for all its flaws, and for all that it has been run down by mismanagement and under-funding, the NHS probably represents the zenith of democratic collectivism in Britain. This is why the NHS is arguably Britain's most popular institution.
The introduction of various charges and, more significantly, various market-based mechanisms has undermined the democratic element of socialised healthcare a bit. The market-based mechanisms contributed to the creation of a 'postcode lottery', for example. But this only marginally undermines the NHS and not nearly enough for the Tories and their Liberal allies. Luckily for them, New Labour began to lay the ground for a new way of running things when they published their plans to break-up and privatize NHS delivery back in 2008. The New Labour argument was always that as long as the treatment was high quality, and as long as it remained free at the point of delivery (well, they did dabble with the idea of charges for appointments with GPs), then there was nothing to worry about. So, they introduced Private Finance Initiatives, using private capital to build new hospital projects, and allowed private firms to compete for cleaning contracts etc. PFIs massively increased costs and ultimately caused the fiscal crisis of 2006, while the privatization of cleaning services led to MRSA. Not to be deterred, Lord Darzi signalled New Labour's determination to continue with privatizing, allowing the funding base to be administered by private firms, and by abandoning the principle of universal coverage set out to entrench legislative principles that would allow them to introduce charges and levies, and restrict care - a freedom which the NHS does not presently have. The basis for restrictions was provided by the disaggregation of NHS service provision into three levels of care: core, additional, and enhanced services. There would be nothing to stop a commercial provider restricting access to care classified as 'additional' or 'enhanced', or charging for it.
Now, radicalising New Labour's proposals, the Tories are going to allow commercial enterprises to administer up to 80% of the NHS budget. They can't very well sell their policy on the grounds of efficiency. Market-based reforms previously introduced have already created new layers of bureaucracy, resulting in - as I pointed out previously - a rise in administrative costs from about 5% of overall budget to 12%. In the private hospitals, administrative costs account for 34% of their total budget. The more the NHS is forced to imitate the private sector, the more administrative costs will rack up. This means less and less funding available for patient care. This is 'efficient' in the sense that Nick Clegg is Noam Chomsky. Coming alongside cuts (don't be fooled by the claims of 'ringfencing' - all local trusts know that cuts are coming and are preparing for it), these reforms mean that the NHS as a service free at the point of delivery, providing quality all-round care for all, is under serious attack. This is being promulgated alongside Michael Gove's attempt to roll back a public, comprehensive, democratically accountable education system. This isn't happening because of the deficit, it isn't happening because people want it, least of all is it happening because of the result of the 2010 general election - please let us be spared that insult. It's an attack on the welfare state, it's an attack on the working class, and it's an attack on democracy. It's time for a democratic revolution.
Labels: capitalism, democracy, health care, inequality, neoliberalism, NHS, socialism
Thursday, August 20, 2009
American psychos posted by Richard Seymour

This being the depressingly typical way in which politics is done in America, it has been rather odd to watch America's unusually large number of cranks get to work attacking Obama and his socialistic Nazi communist Muslim death panels. It has been pointed out that the last attempt at healthcare reform was defeated by the pharmaceutical-healthcare industry, with relatively little mass involvement. This reform process is being conducted with the industry on the inside, as it were - which is one reason why the potential for reform is being progressively eroded. The industry is working very hard to manage and contain reform from within, which it evidently saw coming a mile away (hence astro-turfing PR operations like this). This time, the major public attack is coming from people incited by Palin's claim that health reform would lead to 'death panels' in which bureaucrats get to inflict some foreign eugenics or euthanasia programme in all but name. It has been pointed out that those 'death panels' already exist, and they're all about the stars n stripes. But nonetheless, Palin is being defended by others on the Republican right such as Newt Gingrich, and continues to double down on her assertion when asked. At this one point one recalls the kind of race-baiting hysteria that Palin and the McCain campaign indulged in during the election campaign last year, and the mass audience that clearly existed for it - a minority, but a truculent minority with altogether too many guns. This is yet another expression of exactly the same derangement.
What accounts for it? Clearly, it is only incidentally about Obama's tepid healthcare proposals. The undercurrents of racism being reported at these rallies, and the appearance of heavily armed crowds, clearly indicates that something far greater is at stake. There are some good analyses out there, such as this piece on Al Jazeera, which - despite basically resting on Hofstadter's analysis of the 'paranoid style in American politics' - hits the nail on the head with this:
But the sheer manic intensity of the foam-flecked tirades bursting out in the town halls, so out of proportion to their proximate cause, bespeaks much deeper roots of rage.These are some of the same people who howled "traitor!" and "kill him!" at Sarah Palin's rallies last year.
They are the ones convinced Obama is a Muslim "sleeper agent" who will destroy American values and hand the country over to Osama bin Laden.
The flip side of their rage is fear. They scream: "We want our country back!" Their country is one where white, Christian conservatives rule.
Right-wing Americans are said to believe in small government. Certainly, where that government is doing something to look after poor people, they are opposed to it. But historically, the state's legitimacy has always been unquestioned when it functioned as the racial state. When it functions in a racial capacity, either through its capacity to imprison, police, blockade immigration, or make war, its legitimacy is assured. I am not saying that these functions of the state can be reduced to racism - far from it. If you really want to get to grips with the reasons behind, eg, the rise America's authoritarian prison state, you should consult Ruth Wilson Gilmore. But if you think of America's astonishingly high prison population, the severity of its policing, the regularity and expense of its wars, the byzantine bureaucracies devoted to policing immigration, and the trashing of civil liberties - all of these are accepted by a sufficient number of people because of America's unique racial dynamics. In a similar way, the de-legitimising of the welfare state took the form of barely coded racial slurs about black 'welfare queens'.
The interesting thing is that most of those protesting stand to gain from these reforms, especially if there's a public option with any meaning. It would reduce insurance costs and reduce the incidence of people being denied treatment on the basis of previously existing conditions. But this is channelling an existential crisis for white conservatives, who think of the country as belonging to them. That crisis arises not because of who or what Obama is. All of the crazy stuff about Obama being born in Kenya, or being a secret Muslim, is merely symptomatic. It is because of what the potential new electoral coalitions, flagged up by the 2008 election, might mean for politics in the future. Look at the way protester Katy Abrams put it to Senator Arlen Specter a while ago:
"I don't believe this is just about healthcare. It's not about TARP. It's not about left and right. This is about the systematic dismantling of this country. I'm only thirty-five years old, I've never been interested in politics. You have awakened a sleeping giant. We are tired of this. This is why everybody in this room is so ticked off. I don't want this country turning into... Russia, turning into a socialised country. [applause, cheers, idiotic hooting] My question for you is, what are you going to do to restore this country back to what our founders created, according to the Constitution."
Well, there you are. It's not just about healthcare or any other particular issue. Nothing less than America's survival as the original invention of the founding fathers is at stake. Abrams sounds nuts, but she compares rather favourably to some of her compatriots in the lunacy stakes. The militant rightists who put on such an ugly show last year, particularly those given to prominently bearing arms, are in the tradition of racial 'counter-conspiracy'. From the KKK to the gangs who ethnically cleansed Chinese workers from the Pacific coastal towns, there is a long tradition of reactionaries taking matters into their own hands when the state appears to them to be neglecting its proper role. They argued that they were countering a malicious conspiracy on the part of their victims to destroy the country from within. And of course, since racism defined (and still defines) labour markets, state practises, political communities, etc., it was usually contiguous with other issues - class rebellion or conscientious objection - so that this kind of 'counter-conspiracy' could shade easily into anti-Bolshevism, pogroms against Mexican workers, union-busting, etc. The language now being deployed, about having to resist tyranny, about having to restore the Constitution, about having to resist the systematic dismantling of the country itself, clearly evokes this tradition and its martial tenor.
At base, this racist hysteria and paranoia isn't about 'status anxieties', nor is it a peculiar cultural tic. It is really about the possible threat of class dislocation and downward social mobility for relatively well-to-do whites, a threat that is being amplified by the recession. For such people, whose privileges have always been expressed through private property (however modest their actual possessions may be), the idea of any trend toward 'socialisation' really does seem menacing, weird, alien, threatening. They really want to believe that they can return to conspicuous consumption, even with the impossible debt levels and high working hours that has sustained such consumption. And they really do believe that this lifestyle, based on some spurious 'free market' values, is mandated in the Constitution, somehow part of the country's genetic make-up, stitched into the blueprints. They really do believe that this crisis for their way of life is a crisis being wrought by nefarious, treasonous others. And there is a ready-made militia movement, with tens of thousands of members already signed up, should they decide they have to take matters into their own hands. And if these people get serious, they'll make Timothy McVeigh look like Eddie Haskell.
Labels: 'socialism', america, barack obama, gop, health care, imperialism, obama, racism, right-wing
Friday, August 14, 2009
America needs humanitarian intervention posted by Richard Seymour
US residents are much less healthy than their English counterparts and these differences exist at all points of the SES distribution ... The US population in late middle age is less healthy than the equivalent British population for diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, myocardial infarction, stroke, lung disease, and cancer ... These differences are not solely driven by the bottom of the SES distribution. In many diseases, the top of the SES distribution is less healthy in the United States as well. [Emphasis added by Next Left]
And more:
With the sole exception of cancer, there exists a sharp negative gradient across both education and income groups in both countries ... As a result, country differences are larger and tend to be more statistically different at the bottom of the social hierarchy than at the top. Level differences between countries are sufficiently large that individuals in the top of the education and income strata in the United States have comparable rates of diabetes and heart disease as those in the bottom of the income and education strata in England."
It's not just that the NHS outperforms the US on most health outcomes. What leaps out at one is the way in which class amplifies the differences. America's psychopathic healthcare system is sacrificing tens of thousands of lives, mainly working class and African American, for the sake of profit. Health advisors and boards of trustees routinely kill people, knowingly, to defend the bottom-line. Right now, those who are scaremongering about the NHS are lobbying vehemently to ensure that nothing about this vile state of affairs ever changes. They aren't stupid enough not to understand the consequences of what they are doing, but the current rate of death and misery is part of creating an optimal investment climate. This is social sadism. This is a humanitarian catastrophe. To remedy this intolerable state of affairs, I propose a lobby or solidarity group to 'Save America' (or 'Save America From Itself', or 'Stop Them Before They Kill Again' - you get the picture). There should be rock concerts in Hyde Park to raise money for the millions of Americans who have no healthcare. Bob Geldof and Bono - and here's the excellent thing - would be totally uninvolved in any of this. Funds should be available for those who have been told by their insurance companies that their life is less important than shareholder value, to pay for an airline ticket to any country where they can get treated properly. And all support should be given to those heroic freedom fighters taking on the inhuman monsters who have been getting away with killing their people for far too long. I bet negative PR like that would get some reforms going pretty fucking quickly.
Labels: capitalism, health care, humanitarian intervention, NHS, socialism, tories, us politics
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
How the socialistic collectivist totalitarian NHS ate my hamster posted by Richard Seymour
Now, this may seem like, if anything, a feel-good story. But readers will surely apprehend the quiet menace of the totalitarian state machine behind it all. After all, as I have been hearing people say in shrill American accents for quite some time now, it means that some bureaucrat gets to decide whether I live or die. I mean, don't you think they call their bosses in the nanny state before operating? How the hell else are they supposed to check whether you fit into one of their communistic quotas? And, on top of being menacing and diabolical, the system is also an inefficient shambles. First of all, the toilet seats are always up, there's no flat-screen television, and you have to share a dormitory with other people. And these nurses - talk about attitude. Eat this, drink that, swallow these, would you like some water, etc etc. Ooh, la-di-fucking-da, look at you. Don't they realise who they're working for? If there was any concept of customer service in these wretched hospitals, they would say 'you have no insurance, so as soon as you can walk, you're out the door'. This so-called 'service', by the way, isn't free: you pay through the nose with your hard earned tax money. In a single year it costs $2815 (or £1706) per person. I could have bought a new nose with that. How dare some bureaucrat tell me how to spend my money? And... wait a minute... someone has just told me that America spends $6719 (or £4072) per person on healthcare every year. You fools! You bloody fools! You've only gone socialist without realising it!
Well, so much for that. In the drive to crush Obama's extremely modest healthcare proposals, much of the US health industry and the Republican right have struck on the original idea of saying that any offense against the holy profit is both foreign and communist. Hence, the debate becomes a spurious, contrived contest not between the actual proposed changes and the actually existing system, but between America and the UK. For example, one of the points that American rightists make about the NHS, amid much paranoid drivel, is that in some of its health outcomes, the NHS underperforms compared to the US system. The obvious answer is: so what? One could retort that on the most important health outcome that matters - health adjusted life expectancy - the UK outdoes the US. But this is beside the point. The NHS is not perfect, and has suffered long periods of underinvestment. Germany and France spend approximately 12% of their GDP on healthcare, but Britain only rose above 6% to approx 8% in the first half of this decade, and you can be sure that's about to fall again. To prove that free and equal access at the point of delivery is a superior system, it is not necessary to prove that the NHS excels on every point. There are also some comical misconstructions, as when Sean Hannity warned viewers about some poor sod from Merseyside who had to resort to supergluing the crown to his tooth because he couldn't find an NHS dentist. Hannity warned that Obama would reduce Americans to such a state if his proposals were passed. He did not realise, or did not care, that the reason for the dearth of NHS dentistry is because of the expansion of the private sector in dental care. Dentists are allowed to operate privately, and make far more money doing so (because they can charge more for basic operations). The reason the guy was looking for an NHS dentist is because he couldn't afford the exorbitant costs the private dentists charge for routine work. Another comical moment arose when a right-wing US investors magazine tried to claim that Stephen Hawking would be considered 'worthless' by the NHS, because of his physical handicap. Hawking retorted: "I wouldn't be here today if it were not for the NHS. I have received a large amount of high-quality treatment without which I would not have survived."
Of course, there is another way of approaching this, which is to consider why the private sector is so scandalously inefficient and wasteful. The NHS has historically had very low administration costs, with about 5% of the overall budget going to admin. Only after the internal market was introduced did it rise significantly, to 12%. In Britain's private hospitals, the administration costs are closer to 34%. (David Rowland, Allyson M. Pollock & Neil Vickers, 'The British Labour Government's Reform of the National Health Service', Journal of Public Health Policy, Vol. 22, No. 4, 2001)
In the United States, 'after exclusions', administration costs amount to 31% of total expenditure, although the overhead is much lower in schemes like Medicare than in private insurance. (Steffie Woolhandler, M.D., M.P.H., Terry Campbell, M.H.A., & David U. Himmelstein, M.D., 'Costs of Health Care Administration in the United States and Canada', New England Journal of Medicine, Vol. 349, No. 8, August 2003) The reasons for this vary, but one indicative example is the massive overheads incurred by US insurance companies, most of which are spent on functions (such as underwriting and marketing) that are totally unnecessary in a public system. Extensive legal bureaucracies and the duplication of capacity also suck up resources. And, of course, the fact that someone has to walk away with profit is important - the top ten US health insurers saw their profits rise 428% between 2000 and 2007, from $2.4bn to $12.9bn, mostly paid for by increased premiums. (See this report for figures, [pdf]).
One last thing. How much of this bloated administrative cost goes into denying treatment, and then relentlessly pursuing those who have received treatment to try and get the money back? A congressional probe looked at three companies and found that between 2003 and 2007, 20,000 people had their insurance policies rescinded, so that they could be denied necessary treatment. The saving to the companies would have been hundreds of millions, so undoubtedly this counts as 'efficiency' by their evil standards. Nonetheless, from the point of view of health outcomes, it does seem more than wasteful that there is a bureaucratic apparatus that is designed to kill people, that acts on the perverse incentive to deprive people of mastectomies and chemo that is necessary for their survival. Admittedly, this does call into question the idea that Americans, with their lavish freedom, will never run up against a heartless unfeeling bureaucrat in healthcare. But it does partially explain why no one in the UK, apart from a few cranks on the far right, has any intention whatsoever of emulating America's system.
Labels: 'free markets', capitalism, health care, NHS, profits, socialism
Tuesday, November 18, 2008
Obama's two constituencies posted by Richard Seymour
At its simplest, Obama's electoral coalition can be expressed as comprising Wall Street dough on the one hand, and most oppressed social groups on the other, including African Americans, Latinos, women, and the poorer working class white voters (those earning less than $50,000 a year). As Socialist Worker put it last week:Obama won huge support from the African-American population – some 95 percent of black voters backed him.
He also won two thirds of the Latino vote. This was a significant win – the Latino population favoured George Bush in 2004, and during the primaries they rallied behind Hillary Clinton.
One factor was crucial in breaking support for the Republicans among Latinos – the immigrant rights demonstrations of May 2006.
More than two million Latinos and their supporters came onto the streets to protest against a vicious anti-immigrant bill being pushed by the Republicans.
Among white Americans some 43 percent voted for Obama and 55 for John McCain. But these proportions were reversed for white voters under the age of 30.
And the Democrats registered some of their strongest swings in overwhelmingly white, rural and traditional Republican states such as North Dakota, Utah and Montana.
So there is no doubt that Obama’s appeal spanned racial divisions. But the class composition of his vote tells a more complex story.
If you divide Americans up by their income levels, the poorest households were the ones who voted the most heavily for Obama – 73 percent of voters with an annual family income of less than $15,000 backed him.
As you go up the income level, Obama’s vote steadily drops – until you reach the very top bracket, where this trend reverses.
A majority – 52 percent – of households that earned over $200,000 a year opted for the Democratic candidate.
The victorious Republican electoral coalition in 2004 mobilised quite different groups, with a hardcore of white Christian rightists among them. Bush lost every income layer below $50,000 and won every layer above $50,000. Bush won more Hispanic votes than McCain, but still didn't gain a majority. He lost overwhelmingly among African American voters. What Obama did was to win over white women, who voted 55% for Bush in 2004; he gained a larger majority among voters earning under $50,000 than Kerry had; he increased the Democratic support among both African American and Hispanic voters; and he cut away at Bush's 63% support among those earning $200,000 or more. It is also worth noting that Obama benefited from the demoralisation of a substantial sector of the Republican base. While Obama won a higher share of white voters than Kerry did in 2004, 1 million fewer turned out to vote. The increase in turnout was entirely made up of ethnic minorities.
Obama's appointments, the only major policy signals he can make at the moment, thus far reflect his commitment to the Wall Street constituency rather than to those worst off in American society. Thus, we have endless Clinton-era appointments, Senator Clinton offered the position of Secretary of State (which reports say she has accepted), Republicans offered top posts (it looks as if Robert Gates has been begged to stay on as Secretary of Defense) and a right-wing scumbag from the Chicago boss politics scene and the Democratic Leadership Council named Rahm Emmanuel made chief-of-staff. Thus far, organised labour hasn't got a look-in as far as appointments are concerned, but representatives of corporate America saturate the economic advisory board. Selecting Clinton as Secretary of State indicates that Obama intends to run a hawkish foreign policy, and it also demonstrates that he genuinely wasn't all that upset about the Clinton team's endless race-baiting and crazed smears in the primary. The vast majority of Obama's voters will already have cause for grave disappointment.
To the extent that Obama has to offer something to his majority supporters, he tends toward vagueness, and is already under immense pressure to back off from anything specific. Corporate America is getting terribly worked up about the Employee Free Choice Act, a moderate piece of legislation that they are working to ensure will either be bottled up and killed or watered down to near vacuity. Obama's efforts to 'tweak' the borderline criminal TARP plan includes redirecting some funds to help homeowners, while also protecting US auto manufacturers (to the chagrin of Gordon Brown). But so far the only concrete proposal is $25bn for the car companies. It is simply impossible to imagine that any 'bail-out' for working class households that gets passed will be remotely adequate. It will be better than nothing but, at best, like the modestly redistributive measures Obama has proposed, it will sweeten a lousy deal.
The vital question is, what are the majority of Obama's supporters going to do? For example, if those immigrant workers who marched in such vast numbers in 2006 recognise that they have not so much a friend in the White House as a brief window of opportunity opened up by a slightly more humane policy, they may well be the cutting edge of popular movements of the future. Immigrant groups are already protesting the escalation of ICE raids under Bush, and are pressuring Obama to scale them back. Any reforms they can win will enhance their ability to organise, and all indications are that they are the most militant and effective organisers when given the chance. They will drive up wages and conditions for other workers too. Similarly, if the antiwar movement has learned from its huge setback in 2004, when it subordinated its campaigns to help the pro-war Kerry to victory, then it can limit Obama's scope for widening America's brutal engagements in south Asia and Africa, and for any subversion in Latin America. Obama is already hinting through subordinates that he may be 'flexible' on withdrawal from Iraq, which means he may back off his already vague electoral promises. Given that the Sadrists are about to toss out the gradualist 'withdrawal' plan with its 'status of forces agreement', it would be an ideal point for the antiwar movement to apply pressure for rapid withdrawal with no further delays. The momentum that went into securing Obama's victory shouldn't be dropped for a second. Larry Summers, another Clinton-era revamp in the Obama administration (and former Reaganaut), is warning Wall Street backers that the administration won't be able to diminish the government's involvement in healthcare, and therefore any cost reductions will have to come from efficiency savings. The intriguing thing about this is that the emphasis for the corporate audience is miles away from the promise of increased government involvement to support universal healthcare that Obama has been touting. So, again, this is an issue on which organised labour in particular will have to be actively campaigning about right away. This is becoming a critical issue as state and city budgets plummet due to the economic crisis - so, if Obama can support a bail-out for investment banks, he ought to be able to bail out city treasuries to support existing public services, at a minimum. As it stands, threats of cuts to education and health budgets are already current.
The one advantage that the Left has now is that Obama needs his active constituents. He could not have won 'blue-collar' Pennsylvania as well as Jesse Helms' old state of North Carolina without them, and he can't necessarily repeat his success in 2012 without giving them something. So, there is an opportunity now to decisively shape the agenda of the new administration, precisely because their aim is to contain social movements and stabilise American capitalism. Silence and passivity at this point will simply be rewarded with condescending lectures, put-downs, attacks, and the occasional bit of flattery.
Labels: 'obamamania', american working class, barack obama, democrats, health care, immigration, left, unions
Wednesday, July 11, 2007
On tightening belts posted by Richard Seymour
Soon, American taxpayers will be reminded that they can't afford a national healthcare service...Labels: health care, iraq, sicko
Saturday, June 16, 2007
Sicko posted by Richard Seymour

Michael Moore is a smarter guy than many people realise. I thought that when I saw his last, and I think so again. He is excellent at manipulating the American language of sentimentality, and at ironising at the correct moments as well. He is not a world-class debater, and nor do I credit him with any special academic rigour: but he is exceptionally good at packing well-conceived arguments in a cinematic format, and at hinting at thousands more. In Sicko, he tells Americans that socialism isn't such a bad idea, and that their problem is they have been too politically timid and cowed by anticommunist propaganda to think otherwise.
Much of the film is concerned with showing how ruthless and callous the American healthcare system is, and comparing it with those pertaining to other societies (British viewers may get a patriotic boost, til they see what French people get). As such, the usual stunts come into play: he asks some recent parents in an NHS hospital, "how much did ya have to pay for that baby?"; and he demands that 9/11 volunteers get the same healthcare that the 'evildoers' supposedly get in Guantanamo, before taking them to Cuba to get fixed up (a fairly powerful moment itself). Most of the comedy and the pathos comes from the affected 'culture-shock' in which Moore, playing the legendary oversensitive American nativist, is appalled and intrigued by every detail of how foreigners live. Witnesses explain that you don't pay anything to get your spine fixed here, and Moore grimaces and pretends to be baffled by this communistic experiment. In fact, the state might be obliged to pay you (what the hell is this anyway?). There is also a great deal of discussion about wider political themes, including some entertaining interviews with Tony Benn. However, most of it is concerned with how the US healthcare system actually works, and how it could be simpler and better, and why it wouldn't threaten the earnings of professional middle class doctors, and how the taxes are actually much easier to handle than the bills from medical companies.
However, if there is one thing that stands out in this film, it is how ruthless and brutal the American ruling class really is. It is unmistakeable: they are the master race, and they're out for every last cent. I was going to say what a shock it was that so many ordinary Americans would say on film that they expected the companies to live up to their advertising slogans, but then I compared it to the fact that I myself - for all that I should know better - am still shocked by the extremity and barbarism of the people who run the United States. The conclusion is that one must be as ruthless as they are to get even the slightest penny back from them. Most of those in the film who did get ruthless did so in a highly individualistic fashion, through their lawyers, and left the system intact. What is obviously needed is for the kind of single-minded determination and class solidarity that American CEOs display to be shown on the streets and in workplaces. You could describe it as revolutionary realpolitik: the practises of power, learned and practised by the poor, and the marginalised, and those who like to imagine they're 'middle class'. When Moore showed French protesters filling the streets, he might have added that many of them were on strike: it is (still) in their centrality to the production of profit that American workers are best placed to hit the system most effectively, regardless of what Uncle Sam or his many pollsters or television dramas have to say about it.
Labels: documentary, health care, michael moore, sicko










